Vir Sanghvi
Website  Google.com
   

A commitment to modernity is one of the distinguishing features of the Internet generation


Posted By: Vir Sanghvi   |   Posted On: 23 Jan 2010 12:49 PM

For much of the last year, I have been dabbling with new media. It’s not as though I have given up writing this column or appearing on TV, but I have tried to combine the old media stuff I have always done with some new things.

 

   One of these is the Internet. A year ago, when I launched my own website (www.virsanghvi.com) I was motivated less by an urge to reach an entirely new audience and more by a desire to use the interactive nature of the Internet to see how people were responding to issues and events.

 

   A few months ago, I went on Twitter. And while I don’t necessarily tweet every day and I certainly don’t do the personalised tweets favoured by celebrities (“At boring function; wish I could get away and have fun” etc.) I am reasonably engaged with those who follow me on Twitter.

 

   None of this makes me very knowledgeable about the Internet. My site is still very much a personal operation (the most hits we’ve had for an article is around 30,000-odd, which is not bad for a personal site but hardly compares to the might of something like the HT). I have around 3.35 lakh followers on Twitter, which puts me considerably behind Shashi Tharoor (but ahead of most others) and is probably not enough to base very many generalisations on.

 

   But it has been a fascinating year. The technology interests me much less than the people who use it. I have found that contrary to what old farts (i.e. people like me) may claim, young people are keenly interested in politics, have strong views on many events, and are far more articulate than the generations that preceded them.

 

   At present, bloggers, visitors to websites and tweeters remain a curiosity for traditional media. We rarely accord them the respect they get in the West and only use their views as filler, either for graphics on TV shows or for stories on how celebrities are now on Twitter.

 

   I suspect old media may be making a huge mistake by being so blinkered. There is a new generation out there, expressing itself in ways that were largely unknown even a decade or so ago. As this generation comes of age, its views will determine the path India chooses to follow.

 

   For those of you who are not familiar with the world of the Internet, here are some of the things that I have noticed in my engagement with those who blog, post questions and comments on my website, or tweet. Of course, I do not claim that my experiences are typical or that I have examined a scientifically chosen sample of bloggers. But, for what it’s worth, here’s what I found.

 

ECONOMIC VIEWS: People on the Net tend to have a contemptuous attitude to Marxism and socialist views. The consensus is decidedly right-wing and when Jyoti Basu died, the response to his passing was far less reverential on the web than it was on TV channels or in the press. If there is a new generation of articulate young Marxists out there, then they are not on the web.

 

RELIGIOUS ISSUES: Nobody really cares about the Babri Masjid. Even those who are sympathetic to the BJP have no interest in the construction of a grand Ram temple or in a Hindu renaissance. This generation has no time for ancient disputes about medieval mosques.

 

   On the other hand, there is a growing revulsion over Islamic extremism and fundamentalism. This is less anti-Muslim in origin and more anti-backwardness. This generation hates anything that sounds primitive or regressive. Fundamentalism is seen as going back in time, as being anti-modern and thus, deeply revolting.

 

BJP BLOGGERS: Almost any liberal who has some experience of the Net will tell you that there is a hardcore of pro-BJP bloggers and tweeters who will vigorously defend the Sangh Parivar and viciously attack anybody they regard as ‘pseudo-secular’. On the other hand, there is scant evidence of a hardcore of pro-Congress bloggers and tweeters who respond with equal ferocity.

 

"The distinguishing features of this Internet generation? Well, I would say: a commitment to modernity, a strong nationalist streak and contempt for the ‘socialist’ past and those who represent it."

   Why should this be so? It could be that many NRIs who support the BJP are Internet veterans. Or it could be, as is often rumoured, that the BJP employs a small group of people to scour the Internet every day and to heckle all anti-BJP bloggers.

 

   I don’t know what the truth is. But either way, the Congress is a clear loser on the Net.

 

MANMOHAN SINGH: But the Prime Minister is a clear winner. Except for the hard BJP core, most bloggers and tweeters seem to respect Manmohan Singh. He is by far the most popular politician on the Internet and can rarely do any wrong in the eyes of tweeters.

 

   Partly, this is a reflection of the respect that Dr Singh commands among educated Indians but it is also because the Internet sees him as representing the forces of modernity: pro-liberalisation, clean, well-educated, etc.

 

PAKISTAN AND CHINA: If you were to look at Twitter after a terrorist attack, or some provocative remark from China, you might think that tweeters were all hard-line xenophobes.

 

   But the reality is more complex. This is a strongly patriotic generation that is driven by a vision of India as a potential superpower. Anybody who attacks India or is seen as standing in the way of India’s rise is treated harshly.

 

   There is no generalised hatred of Pakistan on the whole (though there are a lot of hate-India Pakistani sites). If Manmohan Singh says he wants to improve relations with our neighbour, he is applauded. But if Pakistan is seen to back terrorists or to refuse to act against the 26/11 plotters, the tenor of tweets can be high-pitched and hostile.

 

   So, it is with China. Many people believe that China will do everything to prevent India from rising. The anti-China stuff on the Net is usually motivated by this belief. There is no generalised criticism of China of the sort that you see on Western sites: human rights, treatment of Tibetans, etc.

 

PREVIOUS PRIME MINISTERS: While TV and print concentrated on the Emergency in their assessments of Indira Gandhi’s reign on the 25th anniversary of her death, the Internet was less worried about the excesses of that period. For many bloggers, history began in 1980 so they regarded Operation Blue Star as being the most significant event of Mrs Gandhi’s Prime Ministership. Others referred to her image as a strong leader and praised her for standing up on India’s behalf.

 

   Yet, there is much less enthusiasm for Rajiv Gandhi or A.B. Vajpayee. A feeling that Narasimha Rao ended decades of socialism and put India on the path to modernity leads young people to regard him as a great PM.

 

AND FINALLY: The distinguishing features of this Internet generation? Well, I would say: a commitment to modernity, a strong nationalist streak and contempt for the ‘socialist’ past and those who represent it.

 

   Perhaps, these are the views of a whole new generation of affluent urban Indians, not just those who are on the Internet.
 



Comments

Chinmay
24 Feb 2010

Aditya,

No one except you is talking about 'killing Muslims' over a UCC.

And stop treating Muslims like children.

There is nothing horrifying about suggesting that religiosity
takes a backseat in order that the Indian Muslim progresses.

Adults are responsible for their beliefs
and thus must be challenged on them.

As you would confront Hindus about caste,
you must confront Muslims about misogyny,
trigger-happiness, kafir-phobia, and so on...
Aditya Bhatia
15 Feb 2010

Now we are saying fall in line or else. As I said these are our citizens, 300+ million of them. Is it not our responsibility to improve their lot through a balanced approach of understanding their past and preparing them for a better future? Why the need for confrontation? Why this need to demonise and build insecurity? We cant ignore them? It is our duty to improve the lot of these people. We have failed them. Nothing can change that reality.
Aditya Bhatia
15 Feb 2010

There is a need for them to reform, abondon some of their antiqudated rules but honestly guys one of you is suggesting that this needs to be done by force and the other by abondoning the very thing that has defined their existence for centuries. Most educated Muslims have reached a good balance between their faith and their place in the world..but most arent educated in India and that is where we failed them. We did it by keeping them oppressed and with appeasement.
To view all please click on More Comments below

More Comments (57) |   Share with friends   |  
 Post Comment

Your email id will not be published.
Description:

Other Articles

Why is Anil Ambani headline news day after day, week after week?
Why is Parliament disrupted because of the battle? Why is the government of India being forced to defend itself at public fora?
More More
Posted On: 15 Aug 2009
Comments(44)

Pursuits: How much publicity do you give your enemy?
Maoists, Islamists, and fascists have no problem with censorship because they don’t believe in free speech.
More More
Posted On: 31 Oct 2009
Comments(4)

Pursuits: Why are American politicians different from ours?
My theory is that it has to do with the nature of our democracies. The middle class runs America. In India, the middle class has no relevance...
More More
Posted On: 03 Nov 2009
Comments(23)

The media have much to learn from  26/11 -- but so does the government
Whose fault was it that TV served as an impediment in fighting the terrorists? The blame has to be shared by both the TV channels and the government.
More More
Posted On: 24 Nov 2009
Comments(27)

Vinita Kamte’s book exposes the rot at the heart of the police force
Nobody who lives in Bombay can sleep well at night knowing that this is how the police fight terrorism.


More More
Posted On: 14 Dec 2009
Comments(16)

Parallax View
The entire Telengana fiasco tells us something about decision-making in India and about the confusion that envelops our policies on statehood.
More More
Posted On: 26 Dec 2009
Comments(16)

Why is there a move to restore Narasimha Rao’s reputation?
Given this record, why is there a move to restore Narasimha Rao’s reputation? There is no logical explanation.
More More
Posted On: 01 Jan 2010
Comments(53)

Wikipedia is not the most reliable source of information
So why do so many of us depend on a source of information that is so obviously inaccurate? It’s not that we don’t know better.

More More
Posted On: 07 Jan 2010
Comments(30)

The Congress seems less worried by Tharoor’s remarks than the media
Why do you suppose Shashi Tharoor lurches from controversy to controversy? Some of it has to do with his unfamiliarity with the Indian political idiom
More More
Posted On: 13 Jan 2010
Comments(40)

Husain's conception of artistic freedom
The battle for Indian secularism and free speech must be fought here, in India. And not at the feet of some Middle Eastern monarch.
More More
Posted On: 27 Feb 2010
Comments(149)

Even Congressmen fear that America has too much leverage over India
It is hard to see why Washington is letting the goodwill it has enjoyed in India over the last few years slip through its fingers.
More More
Posted On: 27 Mar 2010
Comments(24)

We need the paramilitary forces just as much as we need the army
The time has come for us to rethink our attitudes to these forces and to care more for those jawans who are left bleeding by India’s internal enemies.
More More
Posted On: 09 Apr 2010
Comments(91)

The real problem is the nexus between politicians and policemen
As long as politicians know that they have policemen and spies who will do their dirty work for them, phone tapping will never end.
More More
Posted On: 29 Apr 2010
Comments(3)

Greed never pays, hard work is the only answer
As I read the commentaries that greet the release of the sequel to the original Wall Street, I can’t help feeling that eventually, India got it right.
More More
Posted On: 15 May 2010
Comments(17)

There is a paradox in the way in which the media perceives the UPA government
Now that the UPA has completed the first year of its second term, the mood of the reporting has suddenly changed.
More More
Posted On: 22 May 2010
Comments(9)

Sharad Pawar and the IPL gravy train
If all the teams contain investments from BCCI bigwigs, then clearly, nobody on the board worried unduly about conflict of interest
More More
Posted On: 05 Jun 2010
Comments(10)

Such is the predictability of current events that reporters can sit at home and write stories
When events have this kind of tiresome predictability, I sometimes wonder why we bother to go out and report them.
More More
Posted On: 09 Jul 2010
Comments(12)

Why has the BJP’s response to the Amit Shah case been so disproportionate?
Modi recognises that the Amit Shah case poses an even graver threat to his reputation than the allegations about his role in the Gujarat riots.
More More
Posted On: 30 Jul 2010
Comments(17)

The Pakistani government will be damned before it accepts any help from us
And if this is how their government reacts to an offer of humanitarian aid, then how exactly do we expect Pakistan to react to the peace process?
More More
Posted On: 21 Aug 2010
Comments(11)

Mother Teresa was no saint but she did a lot of good helping those who had lost all hope (NEW)
The birth centenary of Mother Teresa is an occasion for mixed feelings. But now we are better placed to assess her work and her legacy.
More More
Posted On: 28 Aug 2010
Comments(10)




Let's Talk
Let's Talk Will the CWG be a complete disaster - or can things still be salvaged?



Post Your Opinion

Vir Sanghvi


<< Back to Main Page
 
I have A Question For You
Should Suresh Kalmadi resign after the current CWG controversy?



Poll Result
Should Suresh Kalmadi resign after the current CWG controversy?